Smartsheet is a spreadsheet-grid project scheduler with Gantt charts, predecessors, a critical path and baselines; Notion is a docs-and-databases workspace with lighter task tracking, forms and client pages. Pick Smartsheet when the schedule is the product and most stakeholders only view or update it. Pick Notion when the plan has to live next to your docs and a small team wants a Free plan or offline apps. Yearly list prices for five people land close together, so the seat rules decide more than the price does.
For a fixed-date rollout that a whole department watches, I'd start in Smartsheet. For a freelancer or a three-person studio whose briefs, meeting notes and client pages already sit in Notion, I'd stay in Notion and add dependencies to the task database.
Which one fits your project
| Your main requirement | Smartsheet | Notion |
|---|---|---|
| A schedule with predecessors, lag and a critical path | My first choice: four predecessor types, lag and lead, a critical path and one baseline per sheet. Budget for Business or higher if you need baselines. | Dependencies shift dates in three modes. Its dependency help doesn't describe a critical path or a baseline. |
| Many colleagues view or comment while a few people edit | My first choice: Viewers and Contributors cost nothing on paid plans, and Business adds free external Guests. | Anyone on your company's email domain joins as a paid member. Guests are free but invited page by page. |
| Briefs, a wiki and client pages beside the tasks | The sheet is the working surface: rows, columns, comments and attachments. | My first choice: each task is a database page you can write in, next to the wiki and the client pages. |
| A small team that wants a Free plan | No Free plan for new signups since August 28, 2024. You start with a 30-day trial instead. | My first choice: Free has unlimited pages and blocks for one person, limited blocks for two or more members, and 10 guests. |
| Work without a connection | Entirely internet-based. | My first choice: downloaded pages work offline in the desktop and mobile apps. |
| Keep both tools | Rows can arrive from Notion through Zapier, Make or Unito. | Pages can create Smartsheet rows through the same connectors. Neither vendor lists a built-in connector. |
The table gives a starting point. Count three groups before you decide: people who build the plan, people who only watch it, and people outside your domain who need to change something. Those counts move the answer more than any feature list.
A scheduling grid or a docs-and-databases workspace
Smartsheet starts from a grid. Each row is a task, and the columns hold its dates, duration, owner and predecessors. Smartsheet's Gantt view needs at least two date columns that aren't backed by column formulas, and its zoom levels span days through quarters and years. The Pro plan lists Gantt, table, board and calendar views, while the separate Timeline view and Workload tracking are listed on Business.
Notion starts from a page. A project database sits on a page next to the brief, and each task in it opens as a page of its own for notes and decisions. Notion's timeline can use a date range or separate start and end date properties, can show any scale from hours up to years, and can display a table beside the bars. If you go the Notion route, the timeline view setup guide covers the date properties and the first view.
I'd settle this part by asking what your team opens first on Monday. If it's the schedule, Smartsheet's grid is built around it. If it's the brief or the client page, Notion keeps the tasks on the same page as the writing.
How deep does your schedule need to go?
This is where the two tools differ most. Smartsheet documents the mechanics of a project schedule. Notion documents date shifting between linked tasks.
Smartsheet: predecessors, critical path and a baseline
In the new Gantt view, a sheet Owner or Admin opens the Settings icon at the top right and toggles Dependencies on. Grid and legacy Gantt use Project Settings → Dependency Settings → Dependencies enabled. Smartsheet's dependency help offers Finish-to-Start, Finish-to-Finish, Start-to-Start and Start-to-Finish. Lag is measured in working days; in the legacy predecessor dialog, 1d on a Finish-to-Start link starts the next task a working day after its predecessor finishes, while -1d creates lead time. When a predecessor's start or end date changes, the dependent dates adjust immediately.

The trade-off is formulas. Once dependencies are on, you can't use formulas in the Start Date, End Date, Duration, % Complete and Predecessors columns, and parent rows become read-only summaries of their child rows. If your sheet calculates dates with formulas today, plan that change before you switch dependencies on.
Smartsheet's baseline guide covers the reporting layer. The critical path, which the Gantt help calls the longest sequence of tasks that must finish on time to keep the project on schedule, shows in red and updates automatically. A paid Owner or Admin enables the dependencies it needs, and anyone with Editor permission or higher can show or hide it. A baseline adds three non-editable columns: Baseline Start, Baseline Finish and Variance. Only Owners or Admins create one, and each project sheet holds one baseline. Gantt and dependencies are listed from Pro upward. For baseline reporting, budget for Business or higher: the current pricing matrix excludes baselines from Pro, even though the baseline help page still lists Pro.

Notion: dependencies that shift dates
Notion's dependency help describes a dependency as a linear link between tasks, with three date-shifting settings: Shift only when dates overlap, Shift & maintain time between items, and Do not automatically shift. You can also stop shifted items from starting or ending on weekends. Notion's pricing page lists subtasks and dependencies on every plan, Free included. Its dependency help doesn't describe a critical path or a baseline.
An unchanged dependent date can be correct in overlap-only or manual mode, so check the setting before you assume something broke. The guide to dependencies that don't shift dates walks through those checks.
The test I'd apply is simple. If someone will ask "what slipped against the plan we approved?", you need a baseline and a variance column, and that points to Smartsheet. If the question is "what's next, and who owns it?", Notion's dependencies answer it and keep the brief beside the task.

What five people pay on list prices
Both vendors charge per member per month and discount yearly billing. Smartsheet lists Pro at $9 billed yearly or $12 billed monthly, and Business at $19 billed yearly or $24 billed monthly. Notion lists Plus at $10 billed yearly or $12 billed monthly, and Business at $20 billed yearly or $24 billed monthly. Enterprise is custom on both.
| Tier | Smartsheet | Notion |
|---|---|---|
| Free | no Free plan for new signups since August 28, 2024; new signups get a 30-day trial with Business-plan access and no billing information | $0: pages and blocks unlimited for individuals, limited for 2+ members; 10 guests; one chart; basic forms; basic buttons; check Slack-action availability on Free |
| First paid tier | Pro $9 billed yearly, $12 billed monthly; maximum 10 members; Pro is only for new customers | Plus $10 billed yearly, $12 billed monthly |
| Business | $19 billed yearly, $24 billed monthly; minimum 3 members | $20 billed yearly, $24 billed monthly |
| Enterprise | custom pricing | custom pricing (Contact Sales) |
Two Smartsheet conditions sit inside those prices. Pro allows at most 10 members, and the pricing page says Pro is only available to new customers. Business has a 3-member minimum, and a team of 11 or more is past Pro's limit.
| Plan | Calculation | Per year |
|---|---|---|
| Smartsheet Pro | 5 × $9 × 12 | $540 |
| Notion Plus | 5 × $10 × 12 | $600 |
| Smartsheet Business | 5 × $19 × 12 | $1,140 |
| Notion Business | 5 × $20 × 12 | $1,200 |
On monthly billing the gap disappears: the first paid tiers both list $12 per member and the Business tiers both list $24. A $60 yearly difference for five people won't decide this, so I'd move straight to the seat rules in the next section.
Smartsheet's closed Free plan and its trial
The Smartsheet Free plan closed to new signups on August 28, 2024. New signups get a trial instead, and Smartsheet's trial FAQ spells out its terms: 30 days with Business-plan access, and no billing information collected. A trial can't publish Smartsheet forms, sheets, reports or dashboards, and it can't generate API access tokens. If a trial expires, you wait 90 days before you can get another.
Notion's Free plan stays open. A solo freelancer gets unlimited pages and blocks on it. A team of two or more members gets a limited number of blocks, and Notion's pricing FAQ says that once you reach the limit you can still read, edit and organize existing blocks but can't add new ones. A Smartsheet user pays for a plan once the trial ends.
Who needs a paid seat, and what guests can do
Seats decide most of these comparisons, because the two tools price watchers and outside people in different ways.
Smartsheet seat types
- Members are the paid seats.
- Viewers cost nothing: Smartsheet's FAQ says Viewer access is free across paid plans.
- Contributors are free on Pro, Business and Enterprise. Smartsheet's user types page says they view what's shared with them, and with Commenter permission they can comment and add or delete attachments. They can't create items, edit content or share items.
- Guests are free external users on Business and Enterprise only. Shared as an Editor, a Guest can edit unlocked rows and columns, but a Guest can't create Smartsheet items. Smartsheet's user model overview adds that Guests revert to a Contributor seat within 90 days if they don't hold Editor permission or higher on a shared core item.
- Provisional Members get temporary full Member access. Check Provisional Member Settings in Admin Center: the default downgrades unconverted users to free seats, while auto-upgrade converts them to paid Members and can add seats to the bill. Reviews are quarterly on annual plans and monthly on monthly plans.
Pro has no Guest seat. On a Pro plan, external users follow the same Member or Contributor rules as internal users. That matters for client work: on Pro, a client who has to change a date needs a paid Member seat, while on Business the same client can be a free Guest with Editor permission.
Notion members and guests
Notion charges per member on paid plans, and guests are added to individual pages, not to the whole workspace. Notion lists 10 guests on Free, and paid plans allow more guests; guests are free. The catch is the domain rule: people who use one of your organization's email domains are added as paid members, not guests.
So the comparison turns on who's watching. Colleagues on your own domain who only check the plan cost a seat in Notion and nothing in Smartsheet as Viewers or Contributors. Outside clients who edit are free in Smartsheet only as Guests on Business or Enterprise. On Pro they need a Member seat, or a free Contributor seat if they only view and comment. In Notion, outside clients are free guests on any plan, limited to the pages you share. Before inviting anyone in Notion, check whether they should be a guest or a member. If clients need their own view of selected records, the client portal permissions guide shows how to share only the right ones.
Automations, forms and reports by plan
Both tools gate the busy-work features by plan. These are the lines that change a budget.
- Automations: Smartsheet Pro includes 250 automations per month and Business has unlimited automations. Notion's database automations are on paid plans. On Free, Notion offers basic buttons. Its help gives conflicting Slack-notification rules, so check whether that action is available in your Free workspace. Guests can't create database automations. To pick the right Notion trigger, see buttons vs. database automations.
- Forms: Smartsheet Pro includes unlimited sheets, forms and reports, but a trial can't publish forms. Notion forms work for all members on all plans, custom forms start on Plus, and conditional logic is limited to Business and Enterprise. The client intake form guide covers the follow-up once responses arrive.
- Charts and reports: Smartsheet lists reports on Pro and Workload tracking on Business. Notion allows one chart on Free and multiple charts on paid plans, with up to 200 groups and 50 subgroups. For a review page built from views, see the weekly project dashboard.
The tools run the rule or collect the response. Deciding who acts on it, and by when, stays with you in both.
Big sheets and working without a connection
Smartsheet's sheet limits depend on the plan and view. Legacy views allow up to 20,000 rows, 400 columns and 500,000 cells. Enterprise large-scale sheets in new views allow up to 100,000 rows, 400 columns and 1,000,000 cells. These are separate ceilings: rows × columns must also fit the cell limit. Large-scale sheets lose grid view and have feature restrictions, including unsupported automated workflows and mobile access. Imported files cannot exceed 50 MB, and Smartsheet recommends Chrome or Microsoft Edge especially for larger sheets.
Offline is a clear split. Smartsheet's trial FAQ calls it an entirely internet-based application, and the system requirements say you need an internet connection. Notion pages work offline for all members on all plans in the desktop and mobile apps, not in web browsers. Paid plans also download recently visited and favorited pages automatically. A downloaded database automatically brings the first 50 rows of its first view; download additional important rows individually. You can't share a page or edit its permissions while offline.
If your team plans on site, on a plane or anywhere with a weak connection, that alone can point to Notion. If the plan is a large grid that everyone edits at a desk, Smartsheet's limits are the ones you'll care about.
What user ratings and the help pages show
The list prices and seat rules above are the numbers that move a budget. Two more sets fill in the picture: how each tool's own users rate it, and what each vendor documents about behavior that matters for a project.
| Rating out of 5 | Notion | Smartsheet |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | 4.7 from 2,846 reviews | 4.5 from 3,579 reviews |
| Ease of use | 4.4 | 4.3 |
| Value for money | 4.6 | 4.4 |
| Functionality | 4.6 | 4.3 |
| Customer support | 4.4 | 4.3 |
On Software Advice's side-by-side ratings page, both tools score well with their own users and the gap is small. Ratings measure satisfaction, not fit for a schedule-heavy project, so I wouldn't let a 0.2 difference pick your tool.
| Area | Smartsheet | Notion |
|---|---|---|
| Scheduling | Gantt needs two date columns not backed by formulas; zoom spans days to years. Four predecessor types, lag and lead; changes update dependent dates. Driving and summary paths require legacy Gantt. | Timelines use a date range or separate start/end properties and scale from hours to years; dependencies shift dates in three modes with an optional weekend rule |
| Critical path and baseline | Critical path (a paid Owner or Admin enables dependencies; Editors and above show or hide it); one baseline per sheet with three non-editable columns; budget for Business+ baselines | Not described in Notion's dependency help |
| Formulas vs dependencies | With dependencies on, no formulas in Start Date, End Date, Duration, % Complete and Predecessors | No such restriction described in Notion's dependency help |
| Scale | Legacy: 20,000 rows / 400 columns / 500,000 cells. Enterprise new views: 100,000 / 400 / 1,000,000. Limits apply together; large-scale feature restrictions. Imports up to 50 MB; Chrome or Edge recommended for larger sheets. | No row or cell ceiling listed on its pricing page |
| Offline | Entirely internet-based; needs a connection | Pages offline in the desktop and mobile apps on all plans, not in browsers; paid plans auto-download recents and favorites; no sharing or permission edits offline |
| Automations | Pro 250 a month; Business unlimited | Database automations on paid plans; Free has basic buttons; check Slack-action availability; guests can't create database automations |
| Forms | Unlimited forms on Pro; trials can't publish forms | Forms on all plans; conditional logic on Business and Enterprise |
| Charts and reporting | Reports on Pro; Workload tracking on Business | One chart on Free, multiple on paid plans; up to 200 groups and 50 subgroups |
| API and connectors | API for licensed users on Business or higher; no API tokens during a trial | Zapier, Make and Unito connect it to Smartsheet |
| Storage | 20 GB on Pro, 1 TB on Business; maximum attachment 30 MB on Pro, 250 MB on Business | Free: up to 5 MB per file. Paid: up to 5 GB per file. |
Read together, the decision turns on schedule depth and on who works in the plan. Smartsheet documents true project-scheduling mechanics, with predecessor types, lag, a critical path and a baseline, plus very large grids. Notion puts lighter task tracking next to docs, forms and client pages, works offline in its apps and still has a Free plan.
Can you connect Notion and Smartsheet?
You can connect them through a third service. These three connector services cover the pair:
- Zapier: Zapier's Notion and Smartsheet page pairs triggers such as New Data Source Item in Notion with actions such as Create Row in Smartsheet, and offers templates in both directions. Updates made in Notion aren't mirrored automatically, so each kind of change needs its own trigger. Check the actual sheet size and view before enabling a connector. Smartsheet lists features unsupported on large-scale sheets, so don't assume a workflow that runs on a small sheet will scale unchanged.
- Make: Make's Notion and Smartsheet integration builds scenarios from modules, and new users get a free account.
- Unito: Unito describes a flow that creates a Smartsheet row when it finds a Notion page and keeps both in sync.
If you'd rather build it yourself, Smartsheet's integrations page says its API is free for users with a Smartsheet license on a Business plan or higher, and a trial can't generate API tokens.
I'd plan the connection as one-way, rows from pages, unless you deliberately build both directions. The split I'd use keeps the brief and intake in Notion and sends one row per approved task to the Smartsheet schedule. Before anything runs, decide which tool owns each field. If both tools can edit a date, a change in one can overwrite the other.
Run the trial on a real schedule, then move work out
The Smartsheet trial is the cheapest way to settle this, as long as you test the schedule itself. Here's the order I'd follow:
- Start the Smartsheet trial and build one real project: tasks, durations and predecessors, with at least one lag. Turn on the critical path and set a baseline.
- Keep the same project in a Notion database with a date range property, a timeline view and dependencies, and pick the shift mode you'd use.
- Invite the people who'd really use it. The trial runs on Business features, so Guests work during it; on Pro they won't exist, and an outside editor needs a Member seat.
- Skip what the trial can't test: it can't publish forms or generate API tokens.
- Export or upgrade before the trial ends, then choose.
Don't plan around the read-only period. Smartsheet's trial FAQ says sheets from an expired trial become read-only for 90 days before deletion, and 30 days after a cancellation, but its free-plan page gives a shorter window after the trial. To keep your work, the trial FAQ points to two options: change the owner, or export the sheet or report.
Moving a Notion project the other way starts with an export of its database. The Notion database export guide shows what each property becomes in a CSV file. Whatever you bring into Smartsheet still has to fit its sheet limits, and the system requirements cap an imported file at 50 MB.
AI and admin features, briefly
Smartsheet's pricing page lists conversational AI features on Pro and connections to external AI tools on Business. Business also adds admin capabilities, and Enterprise adds Scenario Planning, Portfolios and SAML-based SSO. Notion's pricing page lists a trial of Notion AI on Free and Plus, and Notion Agent and AI Meeting Notes on Business. Neither AI list changes the scheduling answer, so I'd leave AI out of this decision.
Make the choice from one real project
Choose Smartsheet when the project is a schedule first: predecessors with lag, a critical path to watch, a baseline to report against, big grids, and stakeholders who mostly view or comment. Free Viewers and Contributors, plus free Guests on Business, make that crowd cheap to include.
Choose Notion when the plan has to live beside briefs, docs, client pages and forms, when a small team wants a Free plan or offline access in the apps, and when date shifting on dependencies is enough. If Notion wins, I'd start with the Projects and Tasks setup in the Notion project management guide and add a timeline once the dates are clean.
For five people the yearly list prices sit close together, so let the seat rules break the tie. If you want dated tasks with owners and handoffs but not a full scheduler, the Notion vs Asana comparison covers that middle ground. If your grid is really a client database, read Notion vs Airtable for a small client database. If neither fits, the Notion alternatives guide sorts the other options by why you're leaving.